260.423.9551Call
215 East Berry Street
Fort Wayne, IN 46802

Civil Jury Instructions

The Laporte Community School Corporation v. Rosales (Ind. March 20, 2012)

- Originally published March 21, 2012

This child wrongful death case addresses the impropriety of jury instructions regarding a party’s contentions. In this case, the Plaintiff tendered and the trial court gave an instruction regarding the Plaintiff’s allegations of negligence against the Defendant. The instruction informed the jury that the Plaintiff had the burden of proving three elements by a preponderance of the evidence: negligence, proximate cause, and resulting damages. In instructing the jury that the Defendant had the burden of proving negligence, the Court listed actions the Plaintiff alleged were negligent, including failing to implement or monitor a system for health services, failing to properly train its staff, failing to assemble a first aid team, failing to prepare for a foreseeable medical emergency, and failing to supervise those with the responsibility to provide health services. The Court held this instruction was improper and prejudicial. Specifically, the Court stated the instruction could be construed to state that these failures automatically constitute negligence if proven by a preponderance of the evidence. However, a school corporation’s duty is to exercise ordinary and reasonable care. The failure to do the things alleged by the Plaintiff could be evidence of failure to exercise reasonable care. However, the acts in the instruction are not independent duties owed by the school. The Court went on to find the error was prejudicial because it left the jury in doubt as to the law on a material issue. Justice Sullivan dissented, concluding that when looking at the instructions as a whole any ambiguity in the improper instruction did not mislead the jury.

This case should provide substantial clarity regarding propriety of instructing the jury on a party’s contentions. It also provides guidance to appellate practitioners when asserting prejudicial error because of an erroneous instruction. Any party appealing erroneous jury instructions regarding a party’s duty would do well to rely heavily on this case.

Legal Disclaimer

The information contained in the Barrett McNagny LLP website is for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice on any subject matter. Furthermore, the information contained on our website may not reflect the most current legal developments. You should not act upon this information without consulting legal counsel.

Your transmission and receipt of information on the Barrett McNagny LLP website, or sending an e-mail to one of our attorneys or staff, will not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Barrett McNagny LLP. If you need legal advice and want to establish an attorney-client relationship with Barrett McNagny LLP, please contact one of our attorneys by telephone, email, or other means of communication, and allow the attorney to confirm that the firm does not represent other persons or entities involved in the matter and that the firm is willing to accept representation. Until such confirmation is provided by one of our attorneys, you should not transmit information to us that you consider confidential. If you do provide information to us, and no attorney-client relationship is established, the information will not be considered confidential or privileged, and our receipt of such information will not preclude us from representing another client in a matter adverse to you.

Any links to other websites are not intended to be referrals or endorsements of those sites.

An attorney-client relationship will NOT be formed merely by sending an email to Barrett McNagny, LLP or to any of its attorneys. Please do not send any information specific to your legal needs until you obtain approval from a Barrett McNagny, LLP attorney, as the content of such email will not be considered confidential or privileged. By sending us an email, you confirm your understanding of this notification. If you agree, you may use the e-mail links on this page to contact an attorney.
YesNo